The dose claim fits the serving — physically possible
Claimed 1,500.0 mg is 30% of the ≈5,040 mg serving (listing net weight ÷ unit count (single unit — no servings stated)) — within physical limits.
LookCloser record · 198168804582 · methodology v0.1
Create Creatine Monohydrate Gummies for Men & Women
Result
MODERATE public verifiability
Independent lab test found less creatine than labeled 1 documented contradiction — the evidence is below; the conclusion is yours. Evidence availability only; this does not establish safety or effectiveness.
3 of 6 public trust signals found · 2 product-specific concerns
The short read
An independent lab test found less creatine in this product than the amount listed on the label. This means the tested product may not contain the full amount of creatine you expect. The NSF/ANSI 173 certification is on file for this product, covering identity and quantity of contents plus contaminant limits. You can verify the NSF certification by checking the NSF Certified Products Registry online.
Why this result?
We ran this product through public-record checks — label math, barcode registries, FDA recall lists, published lab tests. This banner sums up what those checks could and couldn’t confirm. Green means nothing public contradicted the label — not proof it works or is safe. Gray means the data to check simply isn’t public: a gap, not a verdict. We show the evidence; the conclusion is yours.
Confirmed evidence
What checked out04
These checks found support in the public record. They confirm specific facts, not the product as a whole.
Confirmed
Taken the way the research studied it
Nothing in this listing contradicts how these ingredients were studied (creatine monohydrate). For example, creatine monohydrate: studied as a daily supplement — the effect comes from muscle saturation over weeks, not from timing a dose before a workout. Sources: NIH ODS — Exercise & Athletic Performance fact sheet, ISSN position stand on creatine (PubMed).
Certified by NSF — contents and contaminants checked
NSF’s certified-products registry lists “Create Wellness Creatine Gummies Watermelon” under Create Wellness, Inc. This certification covers identity and quantity of contents plus contaminant limits — not effectiveness. Verified directly against info.nsf.org at build time.
Barcode confirmed in an outside database
Open Food Facts resolves 198168804582 to "Creatine Gummies" (create) — consistent with this listing.
Documented concerns
What needs caution02
These are documented contradictions or claims that need more evidence. They are separate from missing data.
An independent lab found less than the label claims
NOW Foods' published 2024 testing program (HPLC, independent laboratory) reported that this brand's creatine gummies did not meet their label claim. NOW Foods is the tester here, not the brand tested. Brand-level result — the batch you buy may differ.
Dose is lower than studies used
label claims 1500 mg/serving — below the range commonly used in research (3–5 g/day maintenance across trials (short loading phases use more)). A lower dose is not necessarily useless — but it is not the amount the research used. Sources: NIH ODS — Exercise & Athletic Performance fact sheet, ISSN position stand on creatine (PubMed).
Unresolved public record
What is still missing03
We looked for these signals but could not settle them from public sources. A gap is not a strike.
Reviews not analysed yet
Marketplace rating 4.1★ across 877 ratings. Authenticity not analysed: burst, purge and stockout patterns need price/review history.
No label filed with NIH's public catalog
The NIH Dietary Supplement Label Database has no matching label yet. Ingestion lags the market — recorded as a gap, not a strike.
Gummy format note (applies to creatine gummies as a category)
Creatine is stable as dry powder but degrades toward inactive creatinine in moist, acidic media like gummies — the documented cause of widespread failures in published testing.
What to ask and check
What would settle the open questions
Why is this shown?
Everything we couldn’t verify is something a person can still ask about. Rather than leave gaps sitting as dead ends, we turn each one into a specific question — the exact document, citation, or number that would settle it — plus the things you can confirm yourself with the bottle in your hand.
Ask the brand or seller
1
Can you send a clear photo of the full Supplement Facts panel?
It’s the one part of the label required to state what’s inside and how much. A seller who won’t show it before purchase is asking for trust the label would have earned.
2
Is this label filed with NIH’s Dietary Supplement Label Database (DSLD)?
Filing is voluntary, so absence proves nothing — but a filed label puts the full ingredient table on public record where anyone can read it.
3
Why is the creatine monohydrate amount below the dose used in published research?
There can be good answers — a more bioavailable form, a different intended use. Ask for the reasoning and any data behind it.
Most brands and sellers publish a contact route. A clear answer adds evidence to the record; no answer leaves the question open.
Check for yourself — no one’s permission needed
1
Scan the barcode on the package and confirm it reads 198168804582.
A mismatch between the barcode on the box and the one on the listing is worth pausing over — it can indicate a different variant, a repack, or a counterfeit.
2
Look the product up yourself in NSF’s certified-products registry.
Search “Create Wellness, Inc” at info.nsf.org — certification covers contents and contaminants, not effectiveness.
3
Check the lot number and expiry on the bottle against any COA you’re given.
A certificate that doesn’t name your lot doesn’t describe what you’re holding.
These are the open questions on this specific record — not a warning about the product, and not a suggestion to buy or avoid it. Getting them answered is how you decide for yourself.
The full report is free no signup · no paywall
Every check, claim, label read, dose comparison, registry search, source, and date. Free to read, download, and share.
Want to know if this changes?
Supplements are repeat purchases. Formulas get reformulated, lots get recalled, brands finally publish the lab report they were asked for. We can watch this record and email you only if something changes.
Your address is used for this one purpose. No newsletter, no marketing, no third parties, no tracking pixels — and every email carries a one-click unsubscribe that needs no login. We store the address, the record, and the date. Nothing else.
Record built July 21, 2026. Sources: source listing (live fetch) · brand's own storefront · published independent assays (NOW Foods 2024, SuppCo 2025; brand-level) · PubMed · openFDA · Open Food Facts · NIH DSLD · LookCloser ingredient KB. Evidence-tiered statements of documented fact; conclusions belong to the reader. Beta: this report isn’t yet independently archived — treat it as a well-sourced starting point, not a certificate. Evidence-based corrections welcome.