{"schema":"lookcloser/record@0.2","compatible_with":["lookcloser/record@0.1"],"record_id":"849720024534","processing":{"collection_process_version":"2026-07-24.5","last_collected_at":"2026-08-25T05:12:34-0700","last_collection_event":"intake","label_reader_version":"legacy_unversioned","report_schema":"lookcloser/record@0.2","rendered_at":"2026-09-03T13:44:37-0700"},"analysis_status":"complete","processing_gaps":[],"gtin":"849720024534","listing_identifier":"B01N4RDZBA","brand":"BulkSupplements","title":"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Root Extract Powder","listing_title":"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Root Extract Powder - Ashwagandha Supplement, Herbal Supplement - Vegan & Gluten Free, 600mg per Serving, 250g (8.8 oz) (Pack of 1)","identity":{"canonical_gtin":"00849720024534","source_listing_gtin":"00849720024534","listing_identifier":"B01N4RDZBA","product_image":"https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61Dsp0XPzOL.jpg","product_image_status":"retained","product_image_provenance":{"status":"retained","source":"source_listing","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","primary_url":"https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/61Dsp0XPzOL.jpg","image_count":5,"last_attempted":"2026-08-25T05:12:34-0700","attempts":1},"observed_at":"2026-09-01","source_confirmations":["source_listing_gtin","external_barcode_record"],"brand_consistency":{"status":"unknown","compatible":null,"listing_brand":"BulkSupplements","package_brand":null,"match_method":"insufficient_text","similarity":null},"identity_rule":"exact identifiers only; related products are never substituted"},"trademark_owner":null,"trademark_owner_candidates":[],"trademark_owner_status":"not_found","product_manufacturer_link":"not_established","label_responsible_parties":[],"identity_nodes":[],"seller_of_record":null,"seller_of_record_status":"not_collected_founder_gated","consumer_view":{"template":"identity_review","kicker":"The useful read","headline":"The barcode identity checks out · 849720024534.","deck":"The barcode matches, so we are checking the right product rather than a look-alike.","display_mode":"single_home_per_finding","finding_ids":["barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated"],"point_finding_ids":["barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated"],"cards":[{"finding_id":"barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","card_type":"upc_corroborated","question":"owner","tone":"ok","weight":48,"headline":"The barcode identity checks out · 849720024534.","evidence":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder 450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","so_what":"The barcode matches, so we are checking the right product rather than a look-alike.","source":"Barcode / GTIN record","source_links":[],"registry_receipts":[],"evidence_id":"ev-a46eb0fd98f5","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-a46eb0fd98f5","presentation_home":"finding_catalog"}],"research_links":[{"ingredient":"ashwagandha","label":"NIH NCCIH — Ashwagandha","url":"https://www.nccih.nih.gov/health/ashwagandha","scope":"ingredient_context","product_evidence":false},{"ingredient":"ashwagandha","label":"PubMed search: ashwagandha randomized trial","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=ashwagandha+randomized+controlled+trial","scope":"ingredient_context","product_evidence":false}],"open_items":["No FDA recall matched this brand in the current search.","We have not found a public label filing for this exact product.","Brand ownership is not settled in this record."]},"tldr":{"assessment":"checks_confirmed","headline":"UPC independently corroborated","summary":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","lead_finding_id":"barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","key_findings":[{"id":"barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","class":"ok","headline":"UPC independently corroborated","source":"Barcode / GTIN record","scope":"exact_product"}],"documented_concern_count":0,"confirmed_check_count":1,"open_question_count":2,"usage_note":"Decision support, not medical advice or a product recommendation. Missing evidence is a gap, not a strike."},"origin_context":null,"verdict":{"state":"checks_confirmed","headline":"UPC independently corroborated","detail":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","lead_finding_id":"barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","meaning":"Finding-first decision support. Confirmed checks are not endorsements; cautions identify documented facts or bounded comparisons, not medical advice."},"public_verifiability":{"state":"insufficient_public_data","headline":"This product can't be verified from public data","detail":"Neither good nor bad — the checks below show what this listing publishes and what it withholds. Verifiable products publish more.","meaning":"Evidence availability only. Missing public data is a gap, never a strike."},"consistency_score":null,"findings":[{"id":"barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","source":"Barcode / GTIN record","class":"ok","noted":false,"severity":"ok","weight":38,"headline":"UPC independently corroborated","detail":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","proof":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","identity_basis":"gtin","status":"live","source_refs":["barcode_search","source_listing"],"source_url":"https://world.openfoodfacts.org/product/00849720024534","scope":"exact_product","inference_level":"direct_observation","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"ok","evidence_id":"ev-a46eb0fd98f5","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-a46eb0fd98f5","content_fingerprint":"sha256:0d73bfa00dfe4fa1ed910dc77555cbde8bc04934cfb2f1c6c766630e07787c48","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","source_refs":["barcode_search","source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"barcode_search","source_url":"https://world.openfoodfacts.org/product/00849720024534","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"gtin","scope":"exact_gtin"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked Barcode / GTIN record.","found":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing."},"html_anchor":"finding-barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated"},{"id":"label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","source":"Label and serving arithmetic","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"pend","weight":26,"headline":"Label math could not be verified","detail":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, servings per container, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","proof":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, servings per container, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-ac95553197d8","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-ac95553197d8","content_fingerprint":"sha256:b285a915a43cfa6387b4a5d94f5cf25cd70800669a264e838332fb35c5e494d5","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, servings per container, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked Label and serving arithmetic.","found":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, servings per container, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike."},"html_anchor":"finding-label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified"},{"id":"label-and-serving-arithmetic-public-label-filing-not-retained","source":"Label and serving arithmetic","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":19,"headline":"Public label filing not retained","detail":"We have not found a public label filing for this exact product. That is a gap in our records, not evidence that no filing exists.","proof":"We have not found a public label filing for this exact product. That is a gap in our records, not evidence that no filing exists.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-c95becc120d2","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-c95becc120d2","content_fingerprint":"sha256:1f8283430168d56ca9bc50cc7970fe92ad8a0632a006c91aadae34b63be5aa24","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"We have not found a public label filing for this exact product. That is a gap in our records, not evidence that no filing exists.","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked Label and serving arithmetic.","found":"We have not found a public label filing for this exact product. That is a gap in our records, not evidence that no filing exists."},"html_anchor":"finding-label-and-serving-arithmetic-public-label-filing-not-retained","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-label-and-serving-arithmetic-public-label-filing-not-retained"},{"id":"fda-public-records-recall-search-no-match-found-as-of-sep-03-2026","source":"FDA public records","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":19,"headline":"Recall search: no match found (as of Sep 03, 2026)","detail":"This means only that no enforcement record matched the brand name — it does not mean the product was tested, reviewed, or cleared by FDA. New and untested products also have no recall records.","proof":"This means only that no enforcement record matched the brand name — it does not mean the product was tested, reviewed, or cleared by FDA. New and untested products also have no recall records.","identity_basis":"none","status":"live","source_refs":["openfda_search"],"source_url":"https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(recalling_firm:%22BulkSupplements%22+OR+product_description:%22BulkSupplements%22)&limit=5","scope":"search_scope","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"caution","evidence_id":"ev-b3b3b9c911b4","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-b3b3b9c911b4","content_fingerprint":"sha256:316b9247dce80fa8773b9264e05acbfa735d6c615b1afe8fb4bffcb723b95c56","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"This means only that no enforcement record matched the brand name — it does not mean the product was tested, reviewed, or cleared by FDA. New and untested products also have no recall records.","source_refs":["openfda_search"],"source_records":[{"source":"openfda_search","source_url":"https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(recalling_firm:%22BulkSupplements%22+OR+product_description:%22BulkSupplements%22)&limit=5","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"search_only","scope":"product_or_brand","registry_name":"FDA enforcement","identifier":"BulkSupplements","receipt_label":"FDA enforcement search · BulkSupplements"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked FDA public records.","found":"This means only that no enforcement record matched the brand name — it does not mean the product was tested, reviewed, or cleared by FDA. New and untested products also have no recall records."},"html_anchor":"finding-fda-public-records-recall-search-no-match-found-as-of-sep-03-2026","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-fda-public-records-recall-search-no-match-found-as-of-sep-03-2026"},{"id":"keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam","source":"Keepa exact-listing history","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":19,"headline":"This item belongs to a catalog variation family","detail":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","proof":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-ed42b4173a33","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-ed42b4173a33","content_fingerprint":"sha256:d93bce30e7dbf525b47ea13add959fddda66e93ca712b05866364c4694789afb","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant."},"html_anchor":"finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam"},{"id":"keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file","source":"Keepa exact-listing history","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":16,"headline":"180-day review-count history is on file","detail":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 193 on 2025-07-27 to 202 on 2026-08-17 (net +9). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","proof":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 193 on 2025-07-27 to 202 on 2026-08-17 (net +9). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-17ef80344a6b","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-17ef80344a6b","content_fingerprint":"sha256:f48299458cebf4ec5be47d8a0c1fe91293e6011f4dab7333508c38bf55c1ca42","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 193 on 2025-07-27 to 202 on 2026-08-17 (net +9). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 193 on 2025-07-27 to 202 on 2026-08-17 (net +9). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic."},"html_anchor":"finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file"},{"id":"lookcloser-record-check-brand-ownership-record-not-retained","source":"LookCloser record check","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":14,"headline":"Brand ownership record not retained","detail":"This record does not hold an exact, supplement-class public ownership record for the brand. That is a LookCloser coverage gap, not evidence that the brand has no owner or that the product is improper.","proof":"This record does not hold an exact, supplement-class public ownership record for the brand. That is a LookCloser coverage gap, not evidence that the brand has no owner or that the product is improper.","identity_basis":"owner_exact","status":"live","source_refs":["uspto_search"],"source_url":"https://tmsearch.uspto.gov/","scope":"brand_owner","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-09-01","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-6831850c33c7","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-6831850c33c7","content_fingerprint":"sha256:b20588e23c4b700e192db6c05f81577e4bd4a9c65cab00d7ae425cffefc70990","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"This record does not hold an exact, supplement-class public ownership record for the brand. That is a LookCloser coverage gap, not evidence that the brand has no owner or that the product is improper.","source_refs":["uspto_search"],"source_records":[{"source":"uspto_search","source_url":"https://tmsearch.uspto.gov/","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods","scope":"brand","registry_name":"USPTO"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","looked":"LookCloser checked LookCloser record check.","found":"This record does not hold an exact, supplement-class public ownership record for the brand. That is a LookCloser coverage gap, not evidence that the brand has no owner or that the product is improper."},"html_anchor":"finding-lookcloser-record-check-brand-ownership-record-not-retained","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534/full#finding-lookcloser-record-check-brand-ownership-record-not-retained"}],"evidence_records":[{"evidence_id":"ev-a46eb0fd98f5","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated","primary_source":"barcode_search","claim":"UPC independently corroborated","bucket":"checks_out","looked":"LookCloser checked Barcode / GTIN record.","found":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing.","proof":{"detail":"UPCitemdb resolves 849720024534 to \"BulkSupplements.com Ashwagandha Extract Powder  450mg - Brain & Energy Support (\" (BulkSupplements) — consistent with this listing."},"source_refs":[{"source":"barcode_search","source_url":"https://world.openfoodfacts.org/product/00849720024534","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"gtin","scope":"exact_gtin"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:0d73bfa00dfe4fa1ed910dc77555cbde8bc04934cfb2f1c6c766630e07787c48","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-a46eb0fd98f5"},{"evidence_id":"ev-b3b3b9c911b4","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:fda-public-records-recall-search-no-match-found-as-of-sep-03-2026","primary_source":"openfda_search","claim":"Recall search: no match found (as of Sep 03, 2026)","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked FDA public records.","found":"This means only that no enforcement record matched the brand name — it does not mean the product was tested, reviewed, or cleared by FDA. New and untested products also have no recall records.","proof":{"detail":"This means only that no enforcement record matched the brand name — it does not mean the product was tested, reviewed, or cleared by FDA. New and untested products also have no recall records."},"source_refs":[{"source":"openfda_search","source_url":"https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(recalling_firm:%22BulkSupplements%22+OR+product_description:%22BulkSupplements%22)&limit=5","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"search_only","scope":"product_or_brand","registry_name":"FDA enforcement","identifier":"BulkSupplements","receipt_label":"FDA enforcement search · BulkSupplements"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:316b9247dce80fa8773b9264e05acbfa735d6c615b1afe8fb4bffcb723b95c56","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-b3b3b9c911b4"},{"evidence_id":"ev-ac95553197d8","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","primary_source":"source_listing","claim":"Label math could not be verified","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Label and serving arithmetic.","found":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, servings per container, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","proof":{"detail":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, servings per container, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike."},"source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:b285a915a43cfa6387b4a5d94f5cf25cd70800669a264e838332fb35c5e494d5","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-ac95553197d8"},{"evidence_id":"ev-c95becc120d2","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:label-and-serving-arithmetic-public-label-filing-not-retained","primary_source":"source_listing","claim":"Public label filing not retained","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Label and serving arithmetic.","found":"We have not found a public label filing for this exact product. That is a gap in our records, not evidence that no filing exists.","proof":{"detail":"We have not found a public label filing for this exact product. That is a gap in our records, not evidence that no filing exists."},"source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:1f8283430168d56ca9bc50cc7970fe92ad8a0632a006c91aadae34b63be5aa24","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-c95becc120d2"},{"evidence_id":"ev-17ef80344a6b","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file","primary_source":"keepa_history","claim":"180-day review-count history is on file","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 193 on 2025-07-27 to 202 on 2026-08-17 (net +9). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","proof":{"detail":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 193 on 2025-07-27 to 202 on 2026-08-17 (net +9). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic."},"source_refs":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:f48299458cebf4ec5be47d8a0c1fe91293e6011f4dab7333508c38bf55c1ca42","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-17ef80344a6b"},{"evidence_id":"ev-ed42b4173a33","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam","primary_source":"keepa_history","claim":"This item belongs to a catalog variation family","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","proof":{"detail":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant."},"source_refs":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:d93bce30e7dbf525b47ea13add959fddda66e93ca712b05866364c4694789afb","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-ed42b4173a33"},{"evidence_id":"ev-6831850c33c7","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"finding:lookcloser-record-check-brand-ownership-record-not-retained","primary_source":"uspto_search","claim":"Brand ownership record not retained","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked LookCloser record check.","found":"This record does not hold an exact, supplement-class public ownership record for the brand. That is a LookCloser coverage gap, not evidence that the brand has no owner or that the product is improper.","proof":{"detail":"This record does not hold an exact, supplement-class public ownership record for the brand. That is a LookCloser coverage gap, not evidence that the brand has no owner or that the product is improper."},"source_refs":[{"source":"uspto_search","source_url":"https://tmsearch.uspto.gov/","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods","scope":"brand","registry_name":"USPTO"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:b20588e23c4b700e192db6c05f81577e4bd4a9c65cab00d7ae425cffefc70990","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-6831850c33c7"},{"evidence_id":"ev-6f015c41e3b6","record_id":"849720024534","gtin":"849720024534","claim_key":"claim:manufacturing","primary_source":"source_listing","claim":"“in a cGMP-Compliant Facility: Manufactured in a facility that follows current good Manufacturing Practices (cGMP), ensuring a consistent and reliable”","bucket":"partly","looked":"the facility registration or certificate behind the claim","found":"“GMP-certified” describes factory processes, not what is in the bottle. The claim does not name a certifier or public register that a shopper can check.","proof":{"kind":"manufacturing","status":"partly","snippet":"…Produced in a cGMP-Compliant Facility: Manufactured in a facility that follows current good Manufacturing Practices (cGMP), ensuring a consistent and reliable product.…"},"source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"brand_store","source_url":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"brand_domain_only","scope":"brand_or_exact_product"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01","content_fingerprint":"sha256:dac38d1a267a0d4cca5711394e3fd84ee141639a36d1b3dd6821970e26b9b9e9","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-6f015c41e3b6"}],"label_math":{"verdict":"UNKNOWN","claimed_subject":"ashwagandha","claimed_mg":600,"serving_mass_mg":null,"percent_of_serving":null,"serving_mass_source":null,"ambiguity":null,"declared_actives_total_mg":null,"headline_claim_mg":null,"headline_subject":null,"subject_actual_mg":null},"listing_claims":{"dose_claims":[{"subject":"ashwagandha","amount_mg":600,"basis":"per_serving"}],"testing":{"claimed":false,"named_lab_or_certifier":false},"container":{"units":null,"servings":null,"pack_count":1,"units_conflict":false},"marketing_text":[],"certification_text":[],"claim_checks":[{"kind":"manufacturing","label":"Manufacturing claim","snippet":"…Produced in a cGMP-Compliant Facility: Manufactured in a facility that follows current good Manufacturing Practices (cGMP), ensuring a consistent and reliable product.…","looked":"the facility registration or certificate behind the claim","found":"“GMP-certified” describes factory processes, not what is in the bottle. The claim does not name a certifier or public register that a shopper can check.","status":"partly"},{"kind":"efficacy","label":"Benefit claim","snippet":"…It’s commonly chosen by those looking to support balance and resilience in daily life.…","looked":"whether the ingredient doses on the label match the doses used in published research","found":"Ingredient-level evidence for this formula isn’t in our knowledge base yet. Recorded as not assessed — not as a negative.","status":"not-assessed"}],"identity_basis":"source_listing_and_identity_bound_label"},"facts_panel_status":"not_captured","label_photo_read":{"barcode":null,"actives":[],"panel_rows":[]},"resolved_facts_panel":null,"nih_dsld":null,"ingredient_science":null,"nsf_certification":null,"brand_documentation_request":null,"plain_summary":null,"fda_recalls":{"count":0},"offers_at_check_time":[["Retailer listing",21.97]],"price_comparison":{"identity_basis":"upc_gtin","record_gtin":"00849720024534","source_listing_gtin":"00849720024534","retailer_gtin_match":true,"brand_store_gtin_match":false,"seller_identifiers":{},"same_product_only":true,"offers":[["Amazon",21.97]],"offer_records":[{"seller":"Amazon","price":21.97,"currency":"USD","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_gtin","gtin":"00849720024534","rating":null,"price_source":"Submitted listing","price_type":"listing_page"}],"observed_at":"2026-09-01"},"commerce_context":{"observed_at":"2026-09-01","record_gtin":"00849720024534","source_listing":{"status":"exact_listing","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","price":21.97,"price_receipt":{"status":"available","amount":21.97,"currency":"USD","price_type":"listing_page","observed_at":"2026-09-01","source":"Submitted listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","listing_identifier":"B01N4RDZBA"},"rating":null,"rating_count":null,"published_gtin":"00849720024534"},"brand_site":{"status":"store_found_no_product","host":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","url":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","title":null,"variant":null,"price":null,"availability":"unknown","published_gtin":null,"identity_basis":"brand_domain_only","comparison_allowed":false,"candidate_binding":null,"shared_marketing_markers":[],"review_surface":null,"testing_surface":null},"exact_offers":[{"seller":"Amazon","price":21.97,"currency":"USD","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_gtin","gtin":"00849720024534","rating":null,"price_source":"Submitted listing","price_type":"listing_page"}],"external_marketplaces":{"iherb":{"source":"iHerb","status":"eligible_not_checked","identity_basis":"exact_gtin_required","gtin":"00849720024534","search_url":"https://www.iherb.com/search?kw=BulkSupplements+BulkSupplements.com+Ashwagandha+Root+Extract+Powder+-+Ashwagandha+Supplement%2C+Herbal+Supplement+-+Vegan+%26+Gluten+Free%2C+600mg+per+Serving%2C+250g+%288.8+oz%29+%28Pack+of+1%29"},"target":{"source":"Target","status":"eligible_not_checked","identity_basis":"exact_gtin_required","gtin":"00849720024534","search_url":"https://www.target.com/s?searchTerm=BulkSupplements+BulkSupplements.com+Ashwagandha+Root+Extract+Powder+-+Ashwagandha+Supplement%2C+Herbal+Supplement+-+Vegan+%26+Gluten+Free%2C+600mg+per+Serving%2C+250g+%288.8+oz%29+%28Pack+of+1%29"},"walmart":{"source":"Walmart","status":"eligible_not_checked","identity_basis":"exact_gtin_required","gtin":"00849720024534","search_url":"https://www.walmart.com/search?q=BulkSupplements+BulkSupplements.com+Ashwagandha+Root+Extract+Powder+-+Ashwagandha+Supplement%2C+Herbal+Supplement+-+Vegan+%26+Gluten+Free%2C+600mg+per+Serving%2C+250g+%288.8+oz%29+%28Pack+of+1%29"}},"comparison_status":"exact_single_seller","identity_rule":"Prices and reviews are compared only when both pages publish the same UPC/GTIN."},"brand_store":{"host":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","sku_count":250,"supp_count":101,"distinct_trend_cats":7,"cats":["collagen","colostrum","creatine","magnesium","mushroom","sea moss","shilajit"],"specialist":false,"domain_lookup":{"status":"confirmed","brand":"BulkSupplements","host":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","source_url":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","identity_basis":"exact_name_domain_plus_onsite_brand","observed_at":"2026-09-03","product_sitemap_count":8028,"attempts":[{"url":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","outcome":"brand_name_observed"}]},"platform":"headless_or_other","discovery_basis":"exact_name_domain_plus_onsite_brand"},"brand_review_surface":null,"ratings_surface":{"stars":null,"count":null,"observed_at":"2026-09-01","source_ref":"source_listing","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","note":"retailer rating surface; not a product-quality or authenticity verdict"},"review_count_history":{"identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","selection_basis":"built_record","demand_reach":null,"rating_count":{"points":[],"summary":null},"written_review_count":{"points":[["2025-07-27",193],["2025-09-08",194],["2025-09-27",196],["2025-10-05",195],["2025-10-22",194],["2025-11-07",195],["2025-11-28",197],["2025-12-29",198],["2026-01-22",199],["2026-07-30",201],["2026-08-17",202]],"summary":{"start":["2025-07-27",193],"latest":["2026-08-17",202],"net_change":9,"largest_increase":2,"largest_decrease":-1}},"price_snapshot":{"status":"available","amount":21.97,"currency":"USD","price_type":"lowest_new","observed_at":"2026-08-25T12:15:44.664770+00:00","source":"Keepa","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","listing_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","listing_identifier":"B01N4RDZBA","raw_cents":2197},"catalog_snapshot":{"observed_at":"2026-08-25T12:15:44.664770+00:00","listed_since":"2017-01-24","parent_listing_identifier":"B0D1NVMRV5","root_category_id":3760901,"category_path":[{"id":3760901,"name":"Health & Household"},{"id":23675621011,"name":"Vitamins, Minerals & Supplements"},{"id":3764461,"name":"Herbal Supplements"},{"id":23777928011,"name":"Ashwagandha"}],"brand":"BulkSupplements","manufacturer":"BULKSUPPLEMENTS.COM","monthly_sold_estimate":100,"monthly_sold_note":"Source estimate; demand context only, not verified unit sales.","review_counts_last_observed":"2026-08-17","sales_rank_drops":{"30_days":8,"90_days":26,"180_days":59},"out_of_stock_percentage":{"30_days":null,"90_days":null,"180_days":null},"offer_count":6,"context_note":"Rank drops, stockout percentages, offer counts, and monthly-sold values are source observations or estimates; they do not establish product quality."}},"source_registry":{"source_listing":{"type":"product_listing","scope":"exact_listing","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","limitation":null},"barcode_search":{"type":"barcode_registry_search","scope":"exact_gtin","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://world.openfoodfacts.org/product/00849720024534","identity_basis":"gtin"},"nih_dsld_search":{"type":"government_label_catalog","scope":"product_label","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://dsld.od.nih.gov/","identity_basis":"search_only","checked":false,"registry_name":"NIH DSLD","identifier":null,"receipt_label":null},"uspto_search":{"type":"government_trademark_registry","scope":"brand","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://tmsearch.uspto.gov/","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods","checked":false,"registry_name":"USPTO","identifier":null,"receipt_label":null},"openfda_search":{"type":"government_enforcement_search","scope":"product_or_brand","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(recalling_firm:%22BulkSupplements%22+OR+product_description:%22BulkSupplements%22)&limit=5","identity_basis":"search_only","checked":true,"registry_name":"FDA enforcement","identifier":"BulkSupplements","receipt_label":"FDA enforcement search · BulkSupplements"},"nsf_search":{"type":"certification_registry_search","scope":"product_or_brand","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://info.nsf.org/Certified/dietary/","identity_basis":"search_only","checked":false,"registry_name":"NSF","standard":null,"identifier":null,"receipt_label":null},"keepa_history":{"type":"paid_catalog_history","scope":"exact_listing","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B01N4RDZBA","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier"},"brand_store":{"type":"brand_storefront","scope":"brand_or_exact_product","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","identity_basis":"brand_domain_only","comparison_allowed":false,"limitation":null},"pubmed_ashwagandha":{"type":"research_index","scope":"ingredient","observed_at":"2026-09-01","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=ashwagandha+randomized+controlled+trial","identity_basis":"named_ingredient"}},"decision_support":{"disclosure":{"status":"panel_unavailable","summary":"No Supplement Facts rows for this exact product are available.","captured_rows":0,"quantified_rows":0,"separately_quantified_rows":0,"combined_blend_rows":[],"integrity_tells":[],"derived_from":["nih_dsld_search","source_listing"]},"identity_convergence":{"gtin":"00849720024534","confirmations":["source_listing_gtin","external_barcode_record"],"confirmation_count":2,"summary":"2 source(s) matched to this exact product agree on its identity.","not_a_quality_score":true},"research_coverage":{"panel_rows":0,"ingredients_with_reference_context":0,"exact_product_dose_comparisons":0,"dose_comparison_finding_ids":[],"blend_limits_dose_comparison":false,"limitation":"Ingredient context is not product efficacy evidence."},"review_trajectory":{"status":"observed","start":{"date":"2025-07-27","count":193},"latest":{"date":"2026-08-17","count":202},"net_change":9,"span_days":386,"average_change_per_30_days":0.7,"largest_single_interval_increase":2,"identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","limitation":"Count movement does not establish review authenticity; variation families may share counts."},"review_surface_comparison":null,"market":{"offers":[{"seller":"Amazon","price":21.97,"currency":"USD","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_gtin","gtin":"00849720024534","rating":null,"price_source":"Submitted listing","price_type":"listing_page"}],"exact_gtin_only":true,"price_spread":null,"servings_basis":null,"limitation":"Prices are point-in-time observations."},"ownership":{"status":"not_found","owner":null,"candidate_count":0,"brand_age_months":115.3,"manufacturer_link":"not_established","limitation":"Trademark ownership does not establish manufacturer or country of manufacture."},"open_questions":[{"finding_id":"lookcloser-record-check-brand-ownership-record-not-retained","question":"Which exact USPTO registrant is tied to this product's brand use?","source_headline":"Brand ownership record not retained","needed_evidence":"exact-wordmark ownership record","priority":14,"absence_is_not_a_strike":true},{"finding_id":"label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","question":"Do the labeled amounts reconcile with the stated serving and container?","source_headline":"Label math could not be verified","needed_evidence":"Supplement Facts panel matched to this exact product","priority":26,"absence_is_not_a_strike":true}],"connected_signals":[],"evidence_balance":{"documented_concerns":0,"confirmed_checks":1,"neutral_or_open_findings":6,"material_open_questions":2,"concern_finding_ids":[],"confirmation_finding_ids":["barcode-gtin-record-upc-independently-corroborated"]},"claim_scorecard":{"version":"2026-07-23.9","fairness_note":"Couldn’t verify means public proof was not found; it is not a mark against the product. Ingredient research is not treated as a trial of this exact product.","bucket_order":["contradicted","overreaching","checks_out","partly","claimed_no_support","unverified"],"buckets":{"contradicted":[],"overreaching":[],"checks_out":[],"partly":[{"bucket":"partly","claim_key":"claim:manufacturing","claim":"“in a cGMP-Compliant Facility: Manufactured in a facility that follows current good Manufacturing Practices (cGMP), ensuring a consistent and reliable”","check":"“GMP-certified” describes factory processes, not what is in the bottle. The claim does not name a certifier or public register that a shopper can check.","looked":"the facility registration or certificate behind the claim","found":"“GMP-certified” describes factory processes, not what is in the bottle. The claim does not name a certifier or public register that a shopper can check.","finding_id":null,"registry_receipts":[],"evidence_id":"ev-6f015c41e3b6","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-6f015c41e3b6","content_fingerprint":"sha256:dac38d1a267a0d4cca5711394e3fd84ee141639a36d1b3dd6821970e26b9b9e9","observed_at":"2026-09-01","source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"brand_store","source_url":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"brand_domain_only","scope":"brand_or_exact_product"}],"proof":{"kind":"manufacturing","status":"partly","snippet":"…Produced in a cGMP-Compliant Facility: Manufactured in a facility that follows current good Manufacturing Practices (cGMP), ensuring a consistent and reliable product.…"}}],"claimed_no_support":[],"unverified":[]},"counts":{"contradicted":0,"overreaching":0,"checks_out":0,"partly":1,"claimed_no_support":0,"unverified":0},"puffery":[],"consumed_finding_ids":[]},"brand_presence":{"status":"store_found_no_product","host":"https://www.bulksupplements.com","exact_product_page":null,"consumer_meaning":"Brand presence is reported separately from exact-product identity.","absence_is_not_a_strike":true}},"observations":{"offers":[{"seller":"Amazon","price":21.97,"currency":"USD","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B01N4RDZBA","observed_at":"2026-09-01","identity_basis":"exact_gtin","gtin":"00849720024534","rating":null,"price_source":"Submitted listing","price_type":"listing_page"}],"ratings":{"stars":null,"count":null,"observed_at":"2026-09-01","source_ref":"source_listing"},"facts_panel_source":null},"report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/849720024534","methodology":"https://lookcloser.ai/methodology","built_at":"2026-09-03T20:44:37Z","status":"complete","caveats":["Pre-launch beta; not yet independently archived.","Prices and ratings are point-in-time snapshots.","LookCloser does not advise for or against any supplement."],"content_fingerprint":"sha256:dc0d5439fee9b99945b6ee1db6c2272d62635a315c1cd2fac3d2b9bd5ad462ab"}