{"schema":"lookcloser/record@0.2","compatible_with":["lookcloser/record@0.1"],"record_id":"lc-d3937357","processing":{"collection_process_version":"legacy_unversioned","last_collected_at":null,"last_collection_event":null,"label_reader_version":"legacy_unversioned","report_schema":"lookcloser/record@0.2","rendered_at":"2026-07-26T20:46:25-0700"},"analysis_status":"complete","processing_gaps":[],"gtin":null,"listing_identifier":"B0186H4VMG","brand":"GAINS IN BULK GAINSINBULK.COM","title":"Gains in Bulk Instantized Creatine Monohydrate for Men & Women","listing_title":"Gains in Bulk Instantized Creatine Monohydrate for Men & Women, Soluble Pre Workout Powder, Supports Muscle Building, Strength and Performance, Bodybuilding Supplements, Unflavored, 100 Servings","identity":{"canonical_gtin":null,"source_listing_gtin":"00645871744105","listing_identifier":"B0186H4VMG","product_image":"https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71g5i5nKUWL.jpg","product_image_status":"retained","product_image_provenance":{"status":"retained","source":"retained_source_listing","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","primary_url":"https://m.media-amazon.com/images/I/71g5i5nKUWL.jpg","image_count":8,"last_attempted":"2026-07-26T19:54:19-0700","attempts":1,"backfilled_by_renderer":true},"observed_at":"2026-07-26","source_confirmations":[],"brand_consistency":{"status":"unknown","compatible":null,"listing_brand":"GAINS IN BULK GAINSINBULK.COM","package_brand":null,"match_method":"insufficient_text","similarity":null},"identity_rule":"exact identifiers only; related products are never substituted"},"trademark_owner":{"name":"Gains in Bulk","entity":"LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY","country":"ARIZONA, USA","address_filed":"18 W Center Street, Pima, Arizona 85543, UNITED STATES","address_public":"Arizona 85543, UNITED STATES","serial_number":"88156226","registration_number":"5762559","wordmark":"GAINS IN BULK GAINSINBULK.COM","status_description":"SECTION 8 & 15-ACCEPTED AND ACKNOWLEDGED","filed_date":"2018-10-16T00:00:00","first_use_commerce_date":"2015-12-29","registration_date":"2019-05-28","assignment_recorded":false,"goods_services":["IC 005: Dietary supplements; Dietary and nutritional supplements; Dietary food supplements; Enzyme dietary supplements; Enzyme food supplements; Nutritional supplements; Protein supplement shakes; Protein supplements; Protein dietary supplements; Whey protein supplements."],"source":"USPTO Trademark Search","source_url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods"},"trademark_owner_candidates":[],"trademark_owner_status":"found","product_manufacturer_link":"not_established","label_responsible_parties":[],"identity_nodes":[{"role":"trademark_owner","name":"Gains in Bulk","country":"ARIZONA, USA","address":"18 W Center Street, Pima, Arizona 85543, UNITED STATES","source_ref":"uspto_search","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_supplement_class"}],"seller_of_record":null,"seller_of_record_status":"not_collected_founder_gated","consumer_view":{"template":"claim_question","kicker":"The useful read","headline":"The observed listing says it is tested, but names no lab or certifier.","deck":"A testing badge without an issuer or report is a marketing claim, not evidence. Ask for the lab name and lot-specific report.","display_mode":"single_home_per_finding","finding_ids":["certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified"],"point_finding_ids":["certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified"],"cards":[{"finding_id":"certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","card_type":"testing_claimed_no_lab","question":"safety","tone":"warn","weight":80,"headline":"The observed listing says it is tested, but names no lab or certifier.","evidence":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","so_what":"A testing badge without an issuer or report is a marketing claim, not evidence. Ask for the lab name and lot-specific report.","source":"Certification / laboratory record","source_links":[{"label":"Observed listing claim","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","role":"claim surface"}],"registry_receipts":[],"evidence_id":"ev-00ff3ab5d051","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-00ff3ab5d051","presentation_home":"claim_scorecard"},{"finding_id":"uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified","card_type":"owner_identified","question":"owner","tone":"neutral","weight":38,"headline":"🇺🇸 Brand owner: Gains in Bulk · limited liability company, ARIZONA, USA","evidence":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product.","so_what":"This tells you who is behind the brand and where the trademark record points. It does not by itself identify the manufacturer.","source":"USPTO trademark registry","source_links":[],"registry_receipts":[{"source":"uspto_search","url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","label":"USPTO · Registration 5762559","registry_name":"USPTO","standard":null,"identifier":"Registration 5762559"}],"evidence_id":"ev-f51086f391d3","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-f51086f391d3","presentation_home":"ownership_section"}],"research_links":[{"ingredient":"creatine monohydrate","label":"NIH ODS — Exercise & Athletic Performance fact sheet","url":"https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/ExerciseAndAthleticPerformance-HealthProfessional/","scope":"ingredient_context","product_evidence":false},{"ingredient":"creatine monohydrate","label":"Creatine stability by moisture and temperature (PubMed)","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19635041/","scope":"ingredient_context","product_evidence":false}],"open_items":[]},"tldr":{"assessment":"checks_confirmed","headline":"Testing claimed — documentation not found","summary":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","lead_finding_id":"certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","key_findings":[{"id":"uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified","class":"ok","headline":"Exact trademark owner identified","source":"USPTO trademark registry","scope":"brand_owner"}],"documented_concern_count":0,"confirmed_check_count":1,"open_question_count":2,"usage_note":"Decision support, not medical advice or a product recommendation. Missing evidence is a gap, not a strike."},"origin_context":null,"verdict":{"state":"checks_confirmed","headline":"Testing claimed — documentation not found","detail":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","lead_finding_id":"certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","meaning":"Finding-first decision support. Confirmed checks are not endorsements; cautions identify documented facts or bounded comparisons, not medical advice."},"public_verifiability":{"state":"insufficient_public_data","headline":"This product can't be verified from public data","detail":"Neither good nor bad — the checks below show what this listing publishes and what it withholds. Verifiable products publish more.","meaning":"Evidence availability only. Missing public data is a gap, never a strike."},"consistency_score":null,"findings":[{"id":"uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified","source":"USPTO trademark registry","class":"ok","noted":false,"severity":"ok","weight":38,"headline":"Exact trademark owner identified","detail":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product.","proof":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product.","identity_basis":"owner_exact","status":"live","source_refs":["uspto_search"],"source_url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","scope":"brand_owner","inference_level":"direct_observation","observed_at":"2026-07-26","presentation_tone":"ok","evidence_id":"ev-f51086f391d3","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-f51086f391d3","content_fingerprint":"sha256:ef4460c217f5da44cea698f61beb0f5d08c98a297b797fed114f074f09d483c5","registry_receipts":[{"source":"uspto_search","url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","label":"USPTO · Registration 5762559","registry_name":"USPTO","standard":null,"identifier":"Registration 5762559"}],"evidence":{"summary":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product.","source_refs":["uspto_search"],"source_records":[{"source":"uspto_search","source_url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods","scope":"brand","registry_name":"USPTO","identifier":"Registration 5762559","receipt_label":"USPTO · Registration 5762559"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","looked":"LookCloser checked USPTO trademark registry.","found":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product."},"html_anchor":"finding-uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/lc-d3937357/full#finding-uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified"},{"id":"label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","source":"Label and serving arithmetic","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"pend","weight":26,"headline":"Label math could not be verified","detail":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, per-serving dose, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","proof":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, per-serving dose, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-07-26","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-1c22a5b00ba6","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-1c22a5b00ba6","content_fingerprint":"sha256:e815735d4ef98898b1384561b8643b5055a6377ce24a3fe76f53ca0381d27039","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, per-serving dose, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","looked":"LookCloser checked Label and serving arithmetic.","found":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, per-serving dose, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike."},"html_anchor":"finding-label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/lc-d3937357/full#finding-label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified"},{"id":"certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","source":"Certification / laboratory record","class":"gap","noted":true,"severity":"pend","weight":23,"headline":"Testing claimed — documentation not found","detail":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","proof":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","identity_basis":"none","status":"live","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","scope":"search_scope","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-07-26","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-00ff3ab5d051","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-00ff3ab5d051","content_fingerprint":"sha256:de2edea7ee52e751f69b700d6081ef7ed0accb8af93719d07d038f9d2ae33d7e","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","source_refs":["source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","looked":"LookCloser checked Certification / laboratory record.","found":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record."},"html_anchor":"finding-certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/lc-d3937357/full#finding-certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found"},{"id":"keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam","source":"Keepa exact-listing history","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":19,"headline":"This item belongs to a catalog variation family","detail":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","proof":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-07-26","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-e2cf282bdd65","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-e2cf282bdd65","content_fingerprint":"sha256:dd5ce66342d61d1922122582852073b6d37b2f8b0c0dc3117d16a0592df3580a","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant."},"html_anchor":"finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/lc-d3937357/full#finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam"},{"id":"keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file","source":"Keepa exact-listing history","class":"gap","noted":false,"severity":"info","weight":16,"headline":"180-day review-count history is on file","detail":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 318 on 2026-01-29 to 345 on 2026-07-22 (net +27). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","proof":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 318 on 2026-01-29 to 345 on 2026-07-22 (net +27). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","identity_basis":"listing","status":"live","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","scope":"exact_listing","inference_level":"gap","observed_at":"2026-07-26","presentation_tone":"gap","evidence_id":"ev-3397ce0571a3","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-3397ce0571a3","content_fingerprint":"sha256:495c68b908929c01164f745dafdc6e89e385589287cb6a9f653fa2719bca24ae","registry_receipts":[],"evidence":{"summary":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 318 on 2026-01-29 to 345 on 2026-07-22 (net +27). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","source_refs":["keepa_history","source_listing"],"source_records":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 318 on 2026-01-29 to 345 on 2026-07-22 (net +27). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic."},"html_anchor":"finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file","report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/lc-d3937357/full#finding-keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file"}],"evidence_records":[{"evidence_id":"ev-f51086f391d3","record_id":"lc-d3937357","gtin":null,"claim_key":"finding:uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified","primary_source":"uspto_search","claim":"Exact trademark owner identified","bucket":"checks_out","looked":"LookCloser checked USPTO trademark registry.","found":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product.","proof":{"detail":"USPTO lists Gains in Bulk (LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY) in ARIZONA, USA for the exact brand wordmark. This identifies the USPTO mark owner or applicant; it does not by itself prove who manufactures or sells this product."},"source_refs":[{"source":"uspto_search","source_url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods","scope":"brand","registry_name":"USPTO","identifier":"Registration 5762559","receipt_label":"USPTO · Registration 5762559"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","content_fingerprint":"sha256:ef4460c217f5da44cea698f61beb0f5d08c98a297b797fed114f074f09d483c5","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-f51086f391d3"},{"evidence_id":"ev-1c22a5b00ba6","record_id":"lc-d3937357","gtin":null,"claim_key":"finding:label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","primary_source":"source_listing","claim":"Label math could not be verified","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Label and serving arithmetic.","found":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, per-serving dose, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike.","proof":{"detail":"The retained listing evidence does not establish net weight, unit count, per-serving dose, so the dose claim cannot yet be checked against serving arithmetic. This is a neutral evidence gap, not a pass or strike."},"source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","content_fingerprint":"sha256:e815735d4ef98898b1384561b8643b5055a6377ce24a3fe76f53ca0381d27039","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-1c22a5b00ba6"},{"evidence_id":"ev-00ff3ab5d051","record_id":"lc-d3937357","gtin":null,"claim_key":"finding:certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","primary_source":"source_listing","claim":"Testing claimed — documentation not found","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Certification / laboratory record.","found":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record.","proof":{"detail":"The observed listing claims third-party testing without naming a lab or certifier. No product-bound report is retained, so the claim cannot be verified as stated. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record."},"source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","content_fingerprint":"sha256:de2edea7ee52e751f69b700d6081ef7ed0accb8af93719d07d038f9d2ae33d7e","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-00ff3ab5d051"},{"evidence_id":"ev-3397ce0571a3","record_id":"lc-d3937357","gtin":null,"claim_key":"finding:keepa-exact-listing-history-180-day-review-count-history-is-on-file","primary_source":"keepa_history","claim":"180-day review-count history is on file","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 318 on 2026-01-29 to 345 on 2026-07-22 (net +27). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic.","proof":{"detail":"Exact-listing history records written-review counts from 318 on 2026-01-29 to 345 on 2026-07-22 (net +27). Count movements can reflect sales, listing variants, collection resets, or moderation; this history does not establish whether reviews are authentic."},"source_refs":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","content_fingerprint":"sha256:495c68b908929c01164f745dafdc6e89e385589287cb6a9f653fa2719bca24ae","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-3397ce0571a3"},{"evidence_id":"ev-e2cf282bdd65","record_id":"lc-d3937357","gtin":null,"claim_key":"finding:keepa-exact-listing-history-this-item-belongs-to-a-catalog-variation-fam","primary_source":"keepa_history","claim":"This item belongs to a catalog variation family","bucket":"unverified","looked":"LookCloser checked Keepa exact-listing history.","found":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant.","proof":{"detail":"The paid catalog links this exact item to a parent listing. Review counts on public product pages may be shared across sizes, flavors, or other variants, so the count history is listing context — not evidence that reviewers received or tested this exact variant."},"source_refs":[{"source":"keepa_history","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"},{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","content_fingerprint":"sha256:dd5ce66342d61d1922122582852073b6d37b2f8b0c0dc3117d16a0592df3580a","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-e2cf282bdd65"},{"evidence_id":"ev-5b854f538403","record_id":"lc-d3937357","gtin":null,"claim_key":"claim:testing","primary_source":"source_listing","claim":"“TESTED: All Gains in Bulk products are third party tested to ensure”","bucket":"unverified","looked":"the observed listing, retained brand product page, any linked COA or test report; NSF, IFOS, USP, Informed-Sport were not queried","found":"No named laboratory or lot-specific certificate was found for this exact product. No exact brand product page was available for a document check. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record. This is a public-evidence limit, not a finding that testing did not occur.","proof":{"kind":"testing","status":"unverified","snippet":"…THIRD-PARTY TESTED: All Gains in Bulk products are third party tested to ensure purity.…"},"source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"observed_at":"2026-07-26","content_fingerprint":"sha256:5282498ab13d49adffdaaa0051e250edeefac729b1c7c9a7c718f045967dc31b","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-5b854f538403"}],"label_math":{"verdict":"UNKNOWN","claimed_subject":null,"claimed_mg":null,"serving_mass_mg":null,"percent_of_serving":null,"serving_mass_source":null,"ambiguity":null,"declared_actives_total_mg":null,"headline_claim_mg":null,"headline_subject":null,"subject_actual_mg":null},"listing_claims":{"dose_claims":[],"testing":{"claimed":true,"named_lab_or_certifier":false},"container":{"units":null,"servings":100,"pack_count":1,"units_conflict":false},"marketing_text":[],"certification_text":[],"claim_checks":[{"kind":"testing","label":"Quality-testing claim","snippet":"…THIRD-PARTY TESTED: All Gains in Bulk products are third party tested to ensure purity.…","looked":"the observed listing, retained brand product page, any linked COA or test report; NSF, IFOS, USP, Informed-Sport were not queried","found":"No named laboratory or lot-specific certificate was found for this exact product. No exact brand product page was available for a document check. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record. This is a public-evidence limit, not a finding that testing did not occur.","status":"unverified"},{"kind":"efficacy","label":"Benefit claim","snippet":"Gains in Bulk Instantized Creatine Monohydrate for Men & Women, Soluble Pre Workout Powder, Supports Muscle Building, Strength and Performance, Bodybuilding Supplements, ","looked":"whether the ingredient doses on the label match the doses used in published research","found":"Ingredient-level evidence for this formula isn’t in our knowledge base yet. Recorded as not assessed — not as a negative.","status":"not-assessed"}],"identity_basis":"source_listing_and_identity_bound_label"},"facts_panel_status":"not_captured","label_photo_read":{"barcode":null,"actives":[],"panel_rows":[]},"resolved_facts_panel":null,"nih_dsld":null,"ingredient_science":null,"nsf_certification":null,"brand_documentation_request":null,"plain_summary":null,"fda_recalls":null,"offers_at_check_time":[],"price_comparison":{"identity_basis":"not_bound","record_gtin":null,"source_listing_gtin":"00645871744105","retailer_gtin_match":false,"brand_store_gtin_match":false,"seller_identifiers":{},"same_product_only":true,"offers":[],"offer_records":[],"observed_at":"2026-07-26"},"commerce_context":{"observed_at":"2026-07-26","record_gtin":null,"source_listing":{"status":"exact_listing","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","price":89,"price_receipt":{"status":"available","amount":89,"currency":"USD","price_type":"lowest_new","observed_at":"2026-07-27T01:47:21.478366+00:00","source":"Keepa","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","listing_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","listing_identifier":"B0186H4VMG","raw_cents":8900},"rating":null,"rating_count":null,"published_gtin":"00645871744105"},"brand_site":{"status":"not_checked","host":null,"url":null,"title":null,"variant":null,"price":null,"availability":"unknown","published_gtin":null,"identity_basis":"not_checked","comparison_allowed":false,"candidate_binding":null,"shared_marketing_markers":[],"review_surface":null,"testing_surface":null},"exact_offers":[],"external_marketplaces":{"iherb":{"source":"iHerb","status":"blocked_missing_gtin","identity_basis":"exact_gtin_required","gtin":null,"search_url":"https://www.iherb.com/search?kw=GAINS+IN+BULK+GAINSINBULK.COM+Gains+in+Bulk+Instantized+Creatine+Monohydrate+for+Men+%26+Women%2C+Soluble+Pre+Workout+Powder%2C+Supports+Muscle+Building%2C+Strength+and+Performance%2C+Bodybu"},"target":{"source":"Target","status":"blocked_missing_gtin","identity_basis":"exact_gtin_required","gtin":null,"search_url":"https://www.target.com/s?searchTerm=GAINS+IN+BULK+GAINSINBULK.COM+Gains+in+Bulk+Instantized+Creatine+Monohydrate+for+Men+%26+Women%2C+Soluble+Pre+Workout+Powder%2C+Supports+Muscle+Building%2C+Strength+and+Performance%2C+Bodybu"},"walmart":{"source":"Walmart","status":"blocked_missing_gtin","identity_basis":"exact_gtin_required","gtin":null,"search_url":"https://www.walmart.com/search?q=GAINS+IN+BULK+GAINSINBULK.COM+Gains+in+Bulk+Instantized+Creatine+Monohydrate+for+Men+%26+Women%2C+Soluble+Pre+Workout+Powder%2C+Supports+Muscle+Building%2C+Strength+and+Performance%2C+Bodybu"}},"comparison_status":"blocked_missing_gtin","identity_rule":"Prices and reviews are compared only when both pages publish the same UPC/GTIN."},"brand_store":null,"brand_review_surface":null,"ratings_surface":{"stars":null,"count":null,"observed_at":"2026-07-26","source_ref":"source_listing","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","note":"retailer rating surface; not a product-quality or authenticity verdict"},"review_count_history":{"identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","selection_basis":"built_record","demand_reach":null,"rating_count":{"points":[],"summary":null},"written_review_count":{"points":[["2026-01-29",318],["2026-02-08",320],["2026-02-22",322],["2026-03-05",324],["2026-03-16",327],["2026-04-07",328],["2026-04-21",330],["2026-05-05",332],["2026-05-16",331],["2026-05-23",332],["2026-06-07",335],["2026-06-21",336],["2026-07-14",340],["2026-07-22",345]],"summary":{"start":["2026-01-29",318],"latest":["2026-07-22",345],"net_change":27,"largest_increase":5,"largest_decrease":-1}},"price_snapshot":{"status":"available","amount":89,"currency":"USD","price_type":"lowest_new","observed_at":"2026-07-27T01:47:21.478366+00:00","source":"Keepa","source_url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","listing_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","listing_identifier":"B0186H4VMG","raw_cents":8900},"catalog_snapshot":{"observed_at":"2026-07-27T01:47:21.478366+00:00","listed_since":"2015-11-18","parent_listing_identifier":"B0FPDRKNGN","root_category_id":3760901,"category_path":[{"id":3760901,"name":"Health & Household"},{"id":23675621011,"name":"Vitamins, Minerals & Supplements"},{"id":10781161,"name":"Amino Acids"},{"id":3773431,"name":"Creatine"}],"brand":"GAINS IN BULK GAINSINBULK.COM","manufacturer":"Arizona Custom Blends Manufacturing LLC","monthly_sold_estimate":2000,"monthly_sold_note":"Source estimate; demand context only, not verified unit sales.","review_counts_last_observed":"2026-07-22","sales_rank_drops":{"30_days":42,"90_days":120,"180_days":324},"out_of_stock_percentage":{"30_days":null,"90_days":null,"180_days":null},"offer_count":3,"context_note":"Rank drops, stockout percentages, offer counts, and monthly-sold values are source observations or estimates; they do not establish product quality."}},"source_registry":{"source_listing":{"type":"product_listing","scope":"exact_listing","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","limitation":null},"barcode_search":{"type":"barcode_registry_search","scope":"exact_gtin","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://world.openfoodfacts.org/","identity_basis":"not_bound"},"nih_dsld_search":{"type":"government_label_catalog","scope":"product_label","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://dsld.od.nih.gov/","identity_basis":"search_only","checked":false,"registry_name":"NIH DSLD","identifier":null,"receipt_label":null},"uspto_search":{"type":"government_trademark_registry","scope":"brand","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods","checked":true,"registry_name":"USPTO","identifier":"Registration 5762559","receipt_label":"USPTO · Registration 5762559"},"openfda_search":{"type":"government_enforcement_search","scope":"product_or_brand","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://api.fda.gov/food/enforcement.json?search=(recalling_firm:%22GAINS+IN+BULK+GAINSINBULK.COM%22+OR+product_description:%22GAINS+IN+BULK+GAINSINBULK.COM%22)&limit=5","identity_basis":"search_only","checked":false,"registry_name":"FDA enforcement","identifier":"GAINS IN BULK GAINSINBULK.COM","receipt_label":null},"nsf_search":{"type":"certification_registry_search","scope":"product_or_brand","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://info.nsf.org/Certified/dietary/","identity_basis":"search_only","checked":false,"registry_name":"NSF","standard":null,"identifier":null,"receipt_label":null},"keepa_history":{"type":"paid_catalog_history","scope":"exact_listing","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://keepa.com/#!product/1-B0186H4VMG","identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier"},"nih_ods_creatine":{"type":"government_ingredient_reference","scope":"ingredient","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/ExerciseAndAthleticPerformance-HealthProfessional/","identity_basis":"named_ingredient","checked":true,"registry_name":"NIH ODS","identifier":"creatine monohydrate","receipt_label":"NIH ODS — Exercise & Athletic Performance fact sheet"},"pubmed_creatine":{"type":"research_index","scope":"ingredient","observed_at":"2026-07-26","url":"https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/?term=creatine+monohydrate+supplementation","identity_basis":"named_ingredient"}},"decision_support":{"disclosure":{"status":"panel_unavailable","summary":"No Supplement Facts rows for this exact product are available.","captured_rows":0,"quantified_rows":0,"separately_quantified_rows":0,"combined_blend_rows":[],"integrity_tells":[],"derived_from":["nih_dsld_search","source_listing"]},"identity_convergence":{"gtin":null,"confirmations":[],"confirmation_count":0,"summary":"0 source(s) matched to this exact product agree on its identity.","not_a_quality_score":true},"research_coverage":{"panel_rows":0,"ingredients_with_reference_context":0,"exact_product_dose_comparisons":0,"dose_comparison_finding_ids":[],"blend_limits_dose_comparison":false,"limitation":"Ingredient context is not product efficacy evidence."},"review_trajectory":{"status":"observed","start":{"date":"2026-01-29","count":318},"latest":{"date":"2026-07-22","count":345},"net_change":27,"span_days":174,"average_change_per_30_days":4.7,"largest_single_interval_increase":5,"identity_basis":"exact_listing_identifier","limitation":"Count movement does not establish review authenticity; variation families may share counts."},"review_surface_comparison":null,"market":{"offers":[],"exact_gtin_only":true,"price_spread":null,"servings_basis":100,"limitation":"Prices are point-in-time observations."},"ownership":{"status":"found","owner":{"name":"Gains in Bulk","entity":"LIMITED LIABILITY COMPANY","country":"ARIZONA, USA","address_filed":"18 W Center Street, Pima, Arizona 85543, UNITED STATES","address_public":"Arizona 85543, UNITED STATES","serial_number":"88156226","registration_number":"5762559","wordmark":"GAINS IN BULK GAINSINBULK.COM","status_description":"SECTION 8 & 15-ACCEPTED AND ACKNOWLEDGED","filed_date":"2018-10-16T00:00:00","first_use_commerce_date":"2015-12-29","registration_date":"2019-05-28","assignment_recorded":false,"goods_services":["IC 005: Dietary supplements; Dietary and nutritional supplements; Dietary food supplements; Enzyme dietary supplements; Enzyme food supplements; Nutritional supplements; Protein supplement shakes; Protein supplements; Protein dietary supplements; Whey protein supplements."],"source":"USPTO Trademark Search","source_url":"https://tsdr.uspto.gov/#caseNumber=88156226&caseSearchType=US_APPLICATION&caseType=DEFAULT&searchType=statusSearch","identity_basis":"exact_wordmark_and_supplement_goods"},"candidate_count":1,"brand_age_months":128.3,"manufacturer_link":"not_established","limitation":"Trademark ownership does not establish manufacturer or country of manufacture."},"open_questions":[{"finding_id":"certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","question":"Can the testing claim be tied to a named laboratory and this product lot?","source_headline":"Testing claimed — documentation not found","needed_evidence":"lot-specific COA naming the laboratory and matching the product lot","priority":23,"absence_is_not_a_strike":true},{"finding_id":"label-and-serving-arithmetic-label-math-could-not-be-verified","question":"Do the labeled amounts reconcile with the stated serving and container?","source_headline":"Label math could not be verified","needed_evidence":"Supplement Facts panel matched to this exact product","priority":26,"absence_is_not_a_strike":true}],"connected_signals":[],"evidence_balance":{"documented_concerns":0,"confirmed_checks":1,"neutral_or_open_findings":4,"material_open_questions":2,"concern_finding_ids":[],"confirmation_finding_ids":["uspto-trademark-registry-exact-trademark-owner-identified"]},"claim_scorecard":{"version":"2026-07-23.9","fairness_note":"Couldn’t verify means public proof was not found; it is not a mark against the product. Ingredient research is not treated as a trial of this exact product.","bucket_order":["contradicted","overreaching","checks_out","partly","claimed_no_support","unverified"],"buckets":{"contradicted":[],"overreaching":[],"checks_out":[],"partly":[],"claimed_no_support":[],"unverified":[{"bucket":"unverified","claim_key":"claim:testing","claim":"“TESTED: All Gains in Bulk products are third party tested to ensure”","check":"No named laboratory or lot-specific certificate was found for this exact product. No exact brand product page was available for a document check. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record. This is a public-evidence limit, not a finding that testing did not occur.","looked":"the observed listing, retained brand product page, any linked COA or test report; NSF, IFOS, USP, Informed-Sport were not queried","found":"No named laboratory or lot-specific certificate was found for this exact product. No exact brand product page was available for a document check. NSF, IFOS, USP, and Informed-Sport were not checked in this record. This is a public-evidence limit, not a finding that testing did not occur.","finding_id":"certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found","registry_receipts":[],"evidence_id":"ev-5b854f538403","evidence_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/e/ev-5b854f538403","content_fingerprint":"sha256:5282498ab13d49adffdaaa0051e250edeefac729b1c7c9a7c718f045967dc31b","observed_at":"2026-07-26","source_refs":[{"source":"source_listing","source_url":"https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0186H4VMG","observed_at":"2026-07-26","identity_basis":"listing_identifier","scope":"exact_listing"}],"proof":{"kind":"testing","status":"unverified","snippet":"…THIRD-PARTY TESTED: All Gains in Bulk products are third party tested to ensure purity.…"}}]},"counts":{"contradicted":0,"overreaching":0,"checks_out":0,"partly":0,"claimed_no_support":0,"unverified":1},"puffery":[],"consumed_finding_ids":["certification-laboratory-record-testing-claimed-documentation-not-found"]},"brand_presence":{"status":"not_checked","host":null,"exact_product_page":null,"consumer_meaning":"Brand presence is reported separately from exact-product identity.","absence_is_not_a_strike":true}},"observations":{"offers":[],"ratings":{"stars":null,"count":null,"observed_at":"2026-07-26","source_ref":"source_listing"},"facts_panel_source":null},"report_url":"https://lookcloser.ai/p/lc-d3937357","methodology":"https://lookcloser.ai/methodology","built_at":"2026-07-27T03:46:25Z","status":"complete","caveats":["Pre-launch beta; not yet independently archived.","Prices and ratings are point-in-time snapshots.","LookCloser does not advise for or against any supplement."],"content_fingerprint":"sha256:a6fb6ee17000d3241954f30f07944bfa764ebe3fd3bbc587c36192f269694c1e"}